Are Border Collies Good First-Time Owners? An Honest Look

Discover the Border Collie, a breed celebrated for its trainable, alert, and playful nature. Considered a medium-sized dog, Border Collies were originally bred in the United Kingdom for herding and working livestock beginning in the 19th century.

In this post, we share insights from almost 10,000 Sniffspot users, offering practical advice for new and prospective Border Collie owners. Whether you’re considering owning or rescuing a Border Collie yourself or already have one, you’ll find valuable tips on how to care for and enjoy life with a trainable Border Collie.

Border Collies: brilliant, athletic, and intensely loyal. They're the canine equivalent of a four-legged Einstein, but are Border Collies good for first-time owners? As Sniffspot user Courtney shares, "My Border Collie is such a goofball, but so eager to please and learn." That eagerness comes with a need for a "job," plenty of exercise, and a dedicated owner. This isn't just a dog; it's a furry, energetic partner. So, let's explore what it really takes to be a Border Collie owner, drawing on insights from nearly 10,000 Sniffspot users.

Source: Sniffspot Community Breed Survey 2024

Border Collie Essentials: A Quick Overview

• Breed Type: Herding
• Size: Medium
• Life Expectancy: 12 – 15 years
• Healthy Weight Range: 30 – 45 lbs
• Adult Height Range: 18 – 22 in
• Temperament: Trainable, Alert, Playful
• Coat Type: Double, Smooth coats
• Color: Black and white, merle (blue or red), tri-color, and various other combinations

Getting to Know the Border Collie

When living with a Border Collie, 78% of our owners said a large house with a fenced yard is necessary to keep this pet happy. Additionally, 56% of owners said a rural or suburban area with open spaces is also acceptable. This dog is highly trainable by all types of dog owners and owners say the Border Collie learns best with positive reinforcement, consistent routines, enrichment activities, and socialization.

When it comes to exercise, 46% of Sniffspot owners say their Border Collie benefits from high exercise every day, including over 2+ hours of activity a day, including walks, runs, and play sessions. The Sniffspot Border Collie community would not recommend this dog for first-time owners.

Key Takeaways

• Border Collies thrive on activity: These intelligent dogs need a significant amount of exercise (2+ hours daily) and mental stimulation. Ensure you can meet these needs before bringing one home.
• Training is key for a happy Collie: Positive reinforcement, consistent routines, and a "job" will help your Border Collie channel their intelligence and energy positively.
• Experienced owners are often best: Border Collies aren't always ideal for first-time dog owners due to their demanding nature. Research, fostering, and connecting with experienced owners can help you decide if a Border Collie is right for you.

The Border Collie Story: Origins and History

One of the most famous lovers of Collies was Queen Victoria herself. When Queen Victoria spotted this active breed in the latter half of the 19th century, she became an active enthusiast. Aside from Queen Victoria, other notable Collie pet parents are James Dean, Ethan Hawke, and Bon Jovie just to name a few.

Border Collies gained international fame for their intelligence and agility, thriving in competitive trials and obedience sports. They were officially recognized by the American Kennel Club in 1995, and Collie Breed clubs are dedicated to preserving their herding instincts and promoting their capabilities. One of the most intelligent breeds, let’s dive deeper into what makes these pups special.

Key Border Collie Traits and Characteristics

• Temperament: Trainable, Alert, Playful
• Energy Level: High
• Trainability: Highly trainable – Learns commands quickly and responds well to training.
• Grooming needs: Moderate maintenance – Needs regular brushing and periodic baths.
• Good with Kids: Very friendly and social with children
• Good with Other Pets: Very friendly with other pets

Temperament and Personality

Energy Levels and Exercise Needs

Intensity of Exercise

Addressing the Need for "Jobs"

Intelligence and Trainability

Potential for Stubbornness

Nipping and Herding Instincts

Are Border Collies Friendly?

With consistent training, you can hone your Border Collie’s working instinct into a loyal and friendly family dog.

Introducing your pet to positive reinforcement (treats, praise, rewards) and consistent daily training routines early helps them avoid undesirable behaviors like developing anxiety or sensitivities. Our community Border Collie owners comment on their pet’s friendliness:

• Extremely friendly and affectionate, a high drive, and always wants to be around people (JS)
• They’re incredibly sensitive and sweet dogs once they come to trust you. Their intelligence allows for all kinds of fun games and play, and can create a very deep bond through training. (AN)
• Reactivity. Take a border collie and put it in an urban environment and you’ll see reactivity towards any movement (cars, bikes, kids). (Heather)

Training Your Border Collie: Tips and Techniques

As a herding breed, Border Collies benefit from praise and positive reinforcement. They also are more likely to be on their best behavior with consistent physical exercise. Here’s what our Border Collie community recommended based on their experience with their own dog:

• Positive Reinforcement (93%): This includes treats, praise, rewards, and so on for positive behavior.
• Consistent Routines (57%): A consistent training routine allows your pet to get comfortable with expectations.
• Socialization (34%): Socializing your dog with other pets, dogs, and people prepares them to interact with the world.

Recall Training Importance

The “come” command is one of the most important commands you can teach (source). Focus on positive reinforcement, using treats, praise, and rewards. Border Collies thrive on having a "job," and recall training can be a fun, engaging activity. It also satisfies their need for mental stimulation. Avoid calling your dog when they're unlikely to come, except in emergencies. This can undermine your training (source). A reliable recall gives your Border Collie more freedom and strengthens your bond.

Life With a Border Collie: What to Expect

Grooming Your Border Collie

To keep your Border Collie’s coat healthy and up to breed standards, brush them several times a week to manage shedding and prevent mats. Of the coat types for common breeds in the herding group, the coat grooming needs for Border Collies are considered moderate maintenance.

Border Collie Exercise Needs

When medium breeds like Border Collies don’t get sufficient exercise, they’re more likely to act out on undesirable behaviors like developing anxiety or sensitivities. They need consistent training, mental activity, and regular exercise to avoid excess energy.

Meeting the 2+ Hour Exercise Requirement

Think about what your Border Collie enjoys. Many love chasing balls or frisbees, playing tug-of-war, or even just romping around with squeaky toys. Variety is important, so mix up their activities to keep them engaged and stimulated. If you’re looking for inspiration, check out our articles on dog enrichment and top dog trainers for ideas on how to keep your Border Collie entertained and challenged.

Finding Dog-Friendly Spaces with Sniffspot

Sniffspot can help you find the perfect dog-friendly spaces near you. Whether you're looking for dog parks, dog water parks, or even private trails for hiking, Sniffspot connects you with safe and enriching environments where your Border Collie can run, play, and socialize. It's a great way to supplement your dog's daily exercise routine and provide them with the space they need to thrive. Check out our listings and discover the perfect spot for your Border Collie's next adventure.

Feeding Your Border Collie: Diet and Nutrition

With high exercise, Border Collies should eat 2 to 3 cups of vet-recommended food to maintain a healthy weight of around 30 – 45 lbs. However, your Border Collie’s ideal weight and food depend on your pet’s sex, activity level, and age.

Border Collie Health Concerns

Similarly, 22% reported digestive issues like constipation, diarrhea, vomiting, and lack of appetite. Lastly, 17% of Border Collie owners claim their dog struggles with skin conditions like allergies, yeast infections, impetigo, ringworm, alopecia, and folliculitis — a common Border Collie health concern. If you’re worried about any of these health issues above, talk to your Border Collie’s vet.”

Specific Health Concerns to be Aware Of

1. Joint Problems: A significant 26% of Border Collie owners reported their dogs experiencing joint problems, including conditions such as hip dysplasia, arthritis, elbow dysplasia, degenerative issues, and osteosarcoma. These issues tend to become more common as the dog ages, making regular veterinary check-ups crucial for early detection and management.
2. Digestive Issues: Additionally, 22% of owners noted that their Border Collies faced digestive problems, which can manifest as constipation, diarrhea, vomiting, or a lack of appetite. These digestive sensitivities can affect the overall well-being of the dog and may require dietary adjustments or veterinary intervention. If you are looking for a place for your Border Collie to run and play that won't upset their stomach, you can find dog parks near you on Sniffspot.
3. Skin Conditions: Skin health is another area of concern, with 17% of owners reporting that their Border Collies experience various skin conditions. Common issues include allergies, yeast infections, impetigo, ringworm, alopecia, and folliculitis. These conditions can cause discomfort and may require ongoing treatment or management strategies.

Why Border Collie Owners Love Their Dogs

• How intelligent and sensitive they are! Also their working drive. (Brooke )
• My dog picked up on basic commands so quickly! She’s the perfect addition to family households. (M.)
• The intelligence really makes us feel like she loves us and understands why she loves us. (JJ)
• He is smart! He wants to learn and engage with life. It makes you get up even on a day you are feeling extremely down. (Chrissy)

Challenges of Border Collie Ownership

• Lots of energy and training requirements – very smart, but sometimes too smart for her own good. Training has been a long process to build trust and overcome a timid nature. (Anon)
• Energy levels— when not properly fulfilled, can be hard to manage. (Anon)
• Herding at times when it’s inappropriate. They can also be overly sensitive. (Brooke )
• Keeping up with the mental exercise, brain exercise, aerobic exercise, and desensitization exercises is a lot. Make sure you’re committed to regular exercise with this breed! (Jamie)

Financial Commitment of Border Collie Ownership

The initial cost of a Border Collie varies. Adoption fees can start as low as $250, offering a more affordable option. However, if you're looking for a puppy from a reputable breeder, expect to spend considerably more—potentially upwards of $4,000 for a pup from a top breeder. The average price for a purebred puppy is around $3,500, often with a $500 reservation fee.

Beyond the initial purchase, ongoing monthly expenses are crucial. Food costs can range from $25 to $50 per month. Grooming, while relatively low-maintenance for Border Collies, adds another $5 to $15 monthly. Healthcare is more variable, ranging from $40 to $200 per month, depending on your dog's health and any unforeseen vet visits. Pet insurance can help mitigate unexpected veterinary bills, with average annual premiums for Border Collies between $500 and $600, depending on coverage.

Budgeting between $1,500 and $3,000 annually for the total cost of Border Collie ownership is recommended. This includes food, grooming, healthcare, and insurance. Remember, these figures are estimates, and actual costs may vary based on your location, lifestyle, and your dog's individual needs. Careful financial planning will help you enjoy the rewarding experience of Border Collie companionship without unexpected financial strain.

Are Border Collies Good for First-Time Owners?

According to 78% of our Sniffspot community, Border Collies are not a great first-time dog. This comes from their trainable nature and high exercise needs. Border Collie owners say it best:

• He is smart! He wants to learn and engage with life. It makes you get up even on a day you are feeling extremely down. (Chrissy)
• They’re very intelligent and very loyal. Such sweet babies. (Arah)
• Very smart and easily trained also very loyal and loving. (Ryan)
• While I love my Collie, the mental exercise and training sessions are a lot of first-time owners. If you want to avoid undesirable behaviors and work with their herding instinct, it can take a lot of work. They’re bred for herding livestock, so unless you live on a farm this can be hard to manage. (D.)

Why Border Collies Might Not Be Ideal for First-Time Owners

Another key consideration is their need for space. Unless you live on a farm, meeting a Border Collie’s exercise requirements can be challenging. As one owner noted, "Border Collie owners say it best: ... unless you live on a farm this can be hard to manage." 78% of Border Collie owners in our Sniffspot community emphasized the need for a large house with a fenced yard. While 56% mentioned that a rural or suburban environment with open spaces is acceptable, apartment living is generally not suitable for this breed.

Alternatives for First-Time Dog Owners

Before choosing a breed, think realistically about your living situation and lifestyle. Do you have access to dog parks or open spaces for exercise? How much time can you dedicate to training and daily activity? Answering these questions honestly will help you find a dog that thrives in your environment and complements your lifestyle. A good match benefits both you and your dog.

Considering Fostering or Adoption

If you're considering fostering, it's a fantastic way to test whether a Border Collie's energy level and training needs align with your lifestyle. It also provides a temporary home for a dog in need. If you decide to adopt, be prepared for a long-term commitment to providing the exercise, training, and enrichment that will keep your Border Collie happy and well-adjusted. Resources like Sniffspot's dog name database can help you find the perfect name, and our listings for dog-friendly water parks can offer fun and engaging activities for your new companion.

Tips for New Border Collie Owners

Training and Structure for Your Border Collie

• Make sure you have a backyard and the time for daily walks/training. (Laurie)
• Provide your pup with a job or purpose because they long for training and structure. (Emily)
• Additional training is a must! Things like crate training, desensitization exercise, and mental exercise are non-negotiables. (Maxine)

Give Your Border Collie a Job

• Insure you have the time to dedicate to not long, but frequent training and provide them with a job, even if it is doing the normal day-to-day activities. (AC)
• This dog needs a lot of brain exercise and regular exercise. Her cognitive abilities are amazing, and these dogs have an innate ability to understand just what you’re asking for. They need a job! (Dean)
• Make sure you have a job for them. It doesn’t have to be herding, but their biological desire to herd and work should be met somewhere. Agility, rally, obedience work, puzzles, scent work, etc. They thrive when they have a job and ways to keep their mind occupied and fulfilled. If you don’t give them a job they will make one for themselves and you might not like their career choice (Valerie)

Daily Stimulation for Your Border Collie

• Have more than enough time budgeted for training, exercise, and creating an optimal environment. Having patience when things inevitably do not go to plan (Ingrid)
• These dogs need A LOT. Breed-specific enrichment, hard exercise, all-day mental stimulation with structured downtime. (Logan)
• My Collie’s cognitive abilities are top-notch, but that’s because I give him so much physical activity in his daily life. If you want an affectionate family dog, you can’t cut corners with this breed. (L)

Early Socialization for Your Border Collie

• Socialize early and give lots of stimulation. They need a job. (Kenna)
• This breed loves to work so make sure you have a job ready and waiting. (Stephanie)
• By the time they get to their adult size, you should already have a strong physical activity routine and coat grooming routine. Crate training too. Socialize them to everything and anything. (Hannah)

The Importance of Research and Experienced Owner Advice

Our Sniffspot community emphasizes that Border Collies require a significant amount of activity. We're not just talking a quick stroll around the block. Think two-plus hours a day of walks, runs, playtime—the works! These dogs were bred to work, and that instinct to herd and expend energy doesn't disappear just because they're living in a home. If you're not prepared for that level of activity, you might find yourself with a bored, and potentially destructive, Collie. Finding dog-friendly spaces near you can help you meet these needs.

In fact, according to our 2024 Community Dog Breed Survey, 78% of Border Collie owners don't recommend the breed for first-time dog owners. This isn't to say it can't be done, but it does mean going in with your eyes wide open. These dogs thrive on training and structure. They need a "job," whether it's herding sheep (if you happen to have a flock handy!), participating in agility training, or learning complex tricks. Working with a qualified dog trainer can be a game-changer in helping you establish a routine and provide the mental stimulation your Border Collie craves.

Love and Attention Are Not Enough

Our Sniffspot community highlights the importance of breed-specific enrichment. This means understanding their herding instincts and providing outlets for that energy. For example, dog water parks can be a great way to let your Border Collie run and play. It also means recognizing that all-day mental stimulation is key. These dogs are smart, and they need to be challenged. Visiting a dog park can be a great way to provide socialization and exercise, but remember to incorporate other activities like puzzle toys, training sessions, and even scent work to keep their minds engaged. If you're looking for inspiration, check out our resources on dog names—it might spark some fun training ideas!

The reality is that keeping up with a Border Collie's exercise and training requirements is a lot of work. It's a daily commitment, and it's something that every prospective owner needs to consider. As one Sniffspot user shared in our 2024 Community Dog Breed Survey, "Keeping up with the mental exercise, brain exercise, aerobic exercise, and desensitization exercises is a lot. Make sure you’re committed to regular exercise with this breed!" This honesty is crucial. It's not about discouraging people from owning Border Collies, but about ensuring that they understand the commitment involved and are prepared to meet these amazing dogs' needs.

Frequently Asked Questions about the Border Collie

Border Collie Lifespan: How Long Do They Live?

Border Collie Size and Growth

Grooming a Border Collie: How Much is Enough?

To maintain your Border Collie’s coat, it’s important to brush them several times a week to manage shedding and prevent mats. Among herding breeds, Border Collie grooming is categorized as expected.

How Much Exercise Does a Border Collie Need?

Border Collies are excellent companions and flourish with over 2+ hours of activity a day, including walks, runs, and play sessions. Owners of Border Collies note that their dogs particularly enjoy chasing/playing with a ball or frisbee, tug-of-war, and playing with squeaky toys. These pups pick up on basic commands quickly, but regular training is important.

If medium breeds like Border Collies don’t receive enough exercise, they may develop unwanted behaviors. These dogs need ongoing training, mental stimulation, and consistent exercise to channel their energy effectively.

Are Border Collies Good with Children?

Do Border Collies Get Along with Other Pets?

Best Food for a Healthy Border Collie

For optimal health, Border Collies should consume 2 to 3 cups of vet-recommended food to maintain a healthy weight of around 30 – 45 lbs pounds. The exact amount and type of food will depend on your Border Collie’s sex, activity level, and age.

Common Border Collie Health Issues

Additionally, 22% reported digestive issues like constipation, diarrhea, vomiting, and lack of appetite. Finally, 17% of Border Collie owners indicated their dog struggles with skin conditions like allergies, yeast infections, impetigo, ringworm, alopecia, and folliculitis, which are common Border Collie health concerns. If you have concerns about any of these health issues, consult your Border Collie’s veterinarian.

Helpful Resources for Border Collie Owners

Here are some of the most relevant resources for Border Collie owners.

• Best Border Collie Dog Rescues & Shelters
• Most Popular Names for Border Collies
• Heart of Border Collie Rescue
• Border Collie Society of America

• Border Collies: History of the Herding Dog Through Time. (American Kennel Club)
• What to Know About Border Collies? (WebMD)

Related Articles

• Border Collie: Breed Facts, Experience and Tips from 9K+ Owners
• Explore the Border Collie: Genuine Tips from 9,000+ Owners
• How to Train a Herding Dog Breed | Sniffspot

Get safe exercise for your dog by renting a private dog park near you

Explore spots near me